Cam Schlittler built his unanimous American League Cy Young season around a 98 mph four-seam fastball. His curveball produced the highest rate of missed swings among his pitches even though he used it less than one time in 10.

Hitters missed the curve on 44.2% of the swings they took against it during the 2026 regular season, according to MLB Statcast. That was double its 22.1% rate in Schlittler’s first major league season. The curve averaged 86.3 mph in 2026, up from 83.3 in 2025.
Schlittler attributed the change to putting more force behind a pitch he could already throw comfortably at a lower speed. “I feel like I hold my pitches loosely. I don’t grip them too hard,” he told MLB.com in August.
The curve was his best pitch at drawing a miss when hitters swung. His four-seamer accumulated the most run value and did more of the work. It accounted for 44.5% of his pitches and generated a 34.8% miss rate, up from 27.9% in 2025. Opponents batted .163 when an at-bat ended on the four-seamer and .250 when it ended on the curve.
The cutter accounted for roughly a quarter of his pitches, with a 23.9% whiff rate. His sinker made up 19.3% of the mix and drew misses on 16.8% of swings. Opponents hit .179 in at-bats that ended on the sinker. He also threw 28 sliders, too few to give them the same weight as his four most frequent offerings.
Schlittler went 14-6 with an AL-best 1.95 ERA in his first full season in the Yankees’ rotation. He struck out 239 over 193 2/3 innings, tying Jack Chesbro’s total for fourth on the club’s single-season list. All 30 voters put him first. Toronto’s Dylan Cease finished second and Cleveland’s Parker Messick third.
The numbers cover regular-season pitches, the period voters considered. A whiff rate measures misses per swing, and pitch-level batting averages include only the pitch that ended each at-bat.
