The Sporting Page Business Scores
Skip to article
ET
Score options
Full scoreboard
Loading scores…
Connecting to scores…
The Sporting Page

Buster Posey and Chase Utley Face Different Tests on the 2027 Hall Ballot

Posey has his first chance at election, while Utley enters his fourth ballot with 59.1% of the previous vote. Both need 75%.

Buster Posey and Chase Utley are on the 2027 Baseball Hall of Fame ballot together for the first time. The writers considering them have different evidence in front of them. Posey is appearing on a ballot after a career with one club and three World Series championships. Utley received 59.1% of the vote last time and is the leading returning candidate.

San Francisco Giants president of baseball operations Buster Posey speaks during a season-ending news conference at Oracle Park in San Francisco on Sept. 29, 2026. Broadcast still. (NBC Sports Bay Area via MLB.com) (NBC Sports Bay Area via MLB.com)

The National Baseball Hall of Fame announced the 2027 Baseball Writers’ Association of America ballot Monday. Fourteen players are new, including Posey and pitchers Jon Lester, Jake Arrieta and Andrew Miller. Thirteen carried over from last year. A voter can choose up to 10 of the 27 players. The same ballot thus asks each writer to consider the strength of the new candidates and decide what to do with players previously left off.

The career that put Posey on the ballot

Posey’s major awards give writers reference points from the beginning and middle of his career. He was the National League Rookie of the Year in 2010, the first of the San Francisco Giants’ three championships during his time with the team. In 2012, he led the NL with a .336 batting average and won its Most Valuable Player award. The Giants won the World Series again that year and in 2014.

His career included the defensive responsibilities of catching alongside that production. The two come together in the election case because the position gives a voter reason to consider workload and run prevention as well as offensive totals. Posey retired after 2021. That places him on this ballot by the Hall’s standard eligibility timetable and leaves no prior BBWAA percentage to use as a benchmark.

The remaining gap for Utley

Utley’s 259 votes in the 2026 election represented 59.1% of 437 ballots cast. If the same number of writers submits ballots this time, election requires at least 328 votes. That is 69 more than he received in 2026. The actual target will change if turnout does.

Andruw Jones and Carlos Beltrán were elected last time, and the new ballot gives their voters space to consider other players. The 14 newcomers also give those writers new choices. Utley’s vote share can grow if writers reassess his career, add him to a ballot with space or change whom they include. The prior tally establishes how far he had to go at the last count. It says nothing about which of those choices writers will make.

The Hall’s thresholds give the outcome consequences beyond induction. Players who receive at least 5% can stay on the writers’ ballot for up to 10 years. Omar Vizquel is in his last year on this ballot. The Hall will announce the 2027 result on Jan. 19 at 6 p.m. ET.

Reporting notes