The Sporting Page Business Scores
Skip to article
ET
Score options
Full scoreboard
Loading scores…
Connecting to scores…
The Sporting Page

Parker Messick’s ALCS Game 5: How 57 Pitches Produced Only Six Outs

Messick’s changeup generated misses, but hits, walks and extended counts ended his ALCS Game 5 start after two innings.

Parker Messick found more misses than his regular-season miss rate suggested, but Tampa Bay kept him working. His 57 physical pitches produced six outs in ALCS Game 5 on October 18, with the changeup carrying nearly half the workload.

Parker Messick pitching beside an illustrative analysis panel
Parker Messick during ALCS Game 5 on October 18, 2026. Illustrative analytical panel: TSP. (David J. Phillip / AP)

The left-hander threw 28 changeups, 49.1% of his pitches, compared with 23.6% across his 2,948-pitch regular-season baseline. That was an increase of 25.5 percentage points. His four-seamer accounted for 21 pitches, with seven sinkers and one slider completing the mix.

The changeup did miss bats. Rays hitters missed seven of 12 swings against it, while Messick finished with nine misses on 25 swings overall. That 36.0% overall miss rate exceeded the 25.5% baseline. The result was still an inefficient outing because misses did not prevent traffic: five hits and two walks came among the 13 batters he faced.

Messick needed 31 pitches for the first inning. After Yandy Díaz’s opening double, Ryan Vilade walked, Chandler Simpson singled and Jonny DeLuca drew a bases-loaded walk. Liam Hicks’ forceout ended the inning, but the Rays had already made Messick throw more than half his eventual total.

The second inning required another 26 pitches. Jonathan Aranda’s single brought home the second run before Messick struck out Vilade and Junior Caminero. Those final two confrontations alone took 14 pitches.

Caminero’s eight-pitch strikeout shows the distinction between a successful plate appearance and an economical one. Messick opened with consecutive changeup strikes, then threw two changeup balls. Three fouls, against a fastball, changeup and slider, prolonged the count before an 85.8 mph changeup finally drew the miss.

The swing evidence therefore supports the changeup’s value without making it an explanation for efficiency. Three of eight balls put in play reached at least 95 mph, and their average exit velocity was 93.7 mph. That contact sample is small, but it also shows why a higher miss rate alone cannot summarize the outing.

His four-seam average fell from 95.7 mph on 11 first-inning pitches to 94.3 on 10 in the second. Two inning samples do not diagnose fatigue or explain his pitch choices. The clearest finding is the workload itself: seven batters reached on hits or walks, extended counts accumulated, and Cleveland needed its bullpen after two innings.

Pitch selection comparison

Share of all physical pitches. Both samples use a common 0–100% scale.

Changeup

Baseline: 23.6% (696)

Target sample: 49.1% (28)

Four-seam fastball

Baseline: 41.8% (1,231)

Target sample: 36.8% (21)

Sinker

Baseline: 15.0% (442)

Target sample: 12.3% (7)

Slider

Baseline: 6.5% (193)

Target sample: 1.8% (1)

Curveball

Baseline: 8.4% (247)

Target sample: 0.0% (0)

Cutter

Baseline: 4.7% (139)

Target sample: 0.0% (0)

Cumulative physical pitches67031.0Inning 157.0Inning 2
Mean four-seam speed (mph); axis 80–1051058095.7Inning 194.3Inning 2

Four-seam inning sample sizes: inning 1: 11, inning 2: 10. Velocity and workload use separate axes; they do not establish causation.

A revealing plate appearance

Catcher view; pitch centers, not ball size12345678

  1. Changeup, 85.7 mph; 0–0; Called Strike
  2. Changeup, 85.2 mph; 0–1; Swinging Strike
  3. Changeup, 84.1 mph; 0–2; Ball
  4. Changeup, 85.2 mph; 1–2; Ball
  5. 4-Seam Fastball, 95.7 mph; 2–2; Foul
  6. Changeup, 85.8 mph; 2–2; Foul
  7. Slider, 84.2 mph; 2–2; Foul
  8. Changeup, 85.8 mph; 2–2; Swinging Strike

The rectangle uses the first pitch’s recorded strike-zone bounds. Individual bounds remain in the ledger. Numbered markers preserve exact centers and may overlap.

Sources and method

The target ledger contains all 57 physical pitches from Baseball Savant’s gamefeed, matched by play ID, sequence, classification and pre-pitch count to the official final MLB record. Counts reconcile with official pitches, batters faced and strikeouts. Automatic calls and other nonpitch actions are excluded. Innings are calculated from outs.

The regular-season baseline covers 32 Cleveland Guardians starts, 2026-03-30 through 2026-09-27, totaling 2,948 physical pitches. It was previously reconciled game by game and is reused with its source record. All physical pitches remain in pitch-share denominators, including unclassified ones. Swinging strikes, blocked swinging strikes, foul tips and missed bunts count as misses; swings also include fouls and balls put in play. Hard contact is at least 95 mph on measured balls in play. Missing measurements remain unavailable.

The target pitch classifications and velocities are complete. In the regular-season comparison, eight pitches lack spin measurements and eight lack extension measurements; recorded speed and location coverage are complete. Different opponents, small inning samples and game situations limit comparisons.

Complete pitch explorer

57 pitches

Download the complete pitch ledger (CSV)

Every physical pitch in the declared target sample; missing measurements are shown as unavailable.
Date Inning Pitch Hitter Balls before Strikes before Type mph Call rpm Extension ft IVB in Horizontal in Plate x ft Plate z ft Zone bottom ft Zone top ft Exit mph Launch deg
2026-10-18 1 1 Yandy Díaz 0 0 FF 94.8 Called Strike 2255.0 6.633 17.4 -9.1 0.688 2.944 1.629 3.228 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 1 2 Yandy Díaz 0 1 FF 95.2 Ball 2219.0 6.529 17.2 -5.5 0.031 4.031 1.629 3.228 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 1 3 Yandy Díaz 1 1 CH 86.3 Foul 1704.0 6.286 0.6 -17.5 -0.496 1.585 1.629 3.228 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 1 4 Yandy Díaz 1 2 FF 96.0 In play, no out 2240.0 6.477 15.5 -8.4 -0.224 3.384 1.629 3.228 109.2 16.0
2026-10-18 1 5 Jonathan Aranda 0 0 SI 93.4 Foul 2071.0 6.48 8.8 -14.3 1.066 2.649 1.61 3.189 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 1 6 Jonathan Aranda 0 1 CH 86.5 In play, out(s) 2020.0 6.339 2.9 -14.6 0.565 1.906 1.61 3.189 88.3 32.0
2026-10-18 1 7 Ryan Vilade 0 0 CH 86.3 Swinging Strike 1886.0 6.395 3.8 -16.4 0.168 1.548 1.653 3.275 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 1 8 Ryan Vilade 0 1 CH 85.6 Ball 1867.0 6.249 6.6 -16.4 1.269 2.517 1.653 3.275 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 1 9 Ryan Vilade 1 1 FF 95.7 Ball 2311.0 6.433 16.9 -7.4 -1.377 3.814 1.653 3.275 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 1 10 Ryan Vilade 2 1 CH 86.4 Ball 1787.0 6.286 1.3 -17.4 0.964 2.093 1.653 3.275 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 1 11 Ryan Vilade 3 1 CH 85.9 Swinging Strike 1889.0 6.391 2.5 -17.3 -0.344 1.356 1.653 3.275 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 1 12 Ryan Vilade 3 2 FF 96.3 Ball 2264.0 6.542 15.5 -7.3 -0.014 1.175 1.653 3.275 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 1 13 Junior Caminero 0 0 FF 95.9 Ball 2323.0 6.518 18.4 -6.2 -1.521 3.139 1.637 3.244 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 1 14 Junior Caminero 1 0 CH 87.5 Called Strike 2117.0 6.297 1.8 -17.6 0.576 1.764 1.637 3.244 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 1 15 Junior Caminero 1 1 CH 86.2 Ball 1867.0 6.425 3.5 -16.8 0.371 0.715 1.637 3.244 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 1 16 Junior Caminero 2 1 FF 96.1 Foul 2232.0 6.564 16.4 -5.9 -1.078 3.555 1.637 3.244 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 1 17 Junior Caminero 2 2 CH 86.6 Swinging Strike 2040.0 6.216 1.9 -16.6 1.292 1.415 1.637 3.244 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 1 18 Chandler Simpson 0 0 SI 94.6 Called Strike 2167.0 6.425 7.4 -15.8 -0.062 2.302 1.604 3.178 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 1 19 Chandler Simpson 0 1 CH 86.1 Swinging Strike 2046.0 6.38 2.0 -16.0 0.049 1.547 1.604 3.178 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 1 20 Chandler Simpson 0 2 CH 86.9 Ball 2033.0 6.359 2.5 -17.5 1.162 1.305 1.604 3.178 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 1 21 Chandler Simpson 1 2 CH 86.8 Ball 2118.0 6.074 3.5 -17.6 1.386 1.75 1.604 3.178 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 1 22 Chandler Simpson 2 2 FF 96.7 Foul 2391.0 6.612 17.5 -6.4 -0.862 2.776 1.604 3.178 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 1 23 Chandler Simpson 2 2 SI 95.8 In play, no out 2185.0 6.358 9.7 -14.5 -0.091 2.445 1.604 3.178 89.3 -48.0
2026-10-18 1 24 Jonny DeLuca 0 0 CH 86.8 Ball 2018.0 6.161 -0.4 -18.4 1.427 3.081 1.581 3.133 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 1 25 Jonny DeLuca 1 0 FF 95.4 Ball 2180.0 6.648 16.9 -4.8 -0.895 3.532 1.581 3.133 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 1 26 Jonny DeLuca 2 0 FF 94.9 Called Strike 2046.0 6.556 14.3 -4.1 -0.452 3.414 1.581 3.133 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 1 27 Jonny DeLuca 2 1 CH 86.8 Ball 2038.0 6.224 0.6 -17.0 0.958 3.046 1.581 3.133 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 1 28 Jonny DeLuca 3 1 SI 94.4 Ball 2139.0 6.49 10.6 -13.6 -0.775 3.429 1.581 3.133 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 1 29 Liam Hicks 0 0 SI 94.2 Ball 2190.0 6.497 12.2 -15.0 0.121 1.336 1.557 3.086 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 1 30 Liam Hicks 1 0 SI 93.2 Called Strike 2112.0 6.397 11.2 -14.4 0.514 2.137 1.557 3.086 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 1 31 Liam Hicks 1 1 FF 95.7 In play, out(s) 2196.0 6.471 14.8 -7.0 -0.571 1.929 1.557 3.086 110.1 -20.0
2026-10-18 2 32 Ben Williamson 0 0 FF 94.3 Called Strike 2245.0 6.696 17.8 -5.6 -0.181 2.618 1.63 3.23 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 2 33 Ben Williamson 0 1 FF 94.3 In play, no out 2319.0 6.622 15.6 -7.8 -0.16 2.586 1.63 3.23 103.8 2.0
2026-10-18 2 34 Taylor Walls 0 0 CH 84.5 Called Strike 1857.0 6.362 -0.7 -16.1 -0.063 1.522 1.542 3.056 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 2 35 Taylor Walls 0 1 CH 84.9 Ball 1876.0 6.225 2.6 -17.0 0.35 1.299 1.542 3.056 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 2 36 Taylor Walls 1 1 FF 93.8 Swinging Strike 2211.0 6.552 16.2 -7.6 -0.542 2.941 1.542 3.056 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 2 37 Taylor Walls 1 2 FF 94.3 Ball 2201.0 6.417 17.2 -5.6 -0.265 4.268 1.542 3.056 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 2 38 Taylor Walls 2 2 CH 85.1 Foul 2047.0 6.279 3.5 -17.3 0.609 2.379 1.542 3.056 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 2 39 Taylor Walls 2 2 FF 94.0 In play, out(s) 2268.0 6.655 16.9 -6.6 -0.522 3.263 1.542 3.056 68.5 64.0
2026-10-18 2 40 Yandy Díaz 0 0 CH 85.7 Ball 1854.0 6.338 -3.1 -14.0 -0.896 1.656 1.629 3.228 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 2 41 Yandy Díaz 1 0 CH 84.5 In play, no out 1888.0 6.229 0.6 -14.4 0.969 2.609 1.629 3.228 94.5 -12.0
2026-10-18 2 42 Jonathan Aranda 0 0 FF 93.4 Ball 2100.0 6.601 16.8 -5.0 -0.961 2.725 1.61 3.189 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 2 43 Jonathan Aranda 1 0 SI 92.9 In play, run(s) 2057.0 6.492 10.0 -14.8 0.266 1.649 1.61 3.189 85.5 3.0
2026-10-18 2 44 Ryan Vilade 0 0 FF 94.3 Called Strike 2205.0 6.542 16.9 -5.3 -0.723 2.461 1.653 3.275 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 2 45 Ryan Vilade 0 1 CH 86.9 Ball 1846.0 6.184 1.8 -16.4 1.692 2.657 1.653 3.275 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 2 46 Ryan Vilade 1 1 FF 94.3 Ball 2268.0 6.572 17.5 -5.4 -0.97 2.406 1.653 3.275 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 2 47 Ryan Vilade 2 1 FF 94.6 Swinging Strike 2271.0 6.486 16.9 -4.2 0.028 3.794 1.653 3.275 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 2 48 Ryan Vilade 2 2 CH 84.9 Ball 2067.0 6.432 0.1 -17.0 1.388 1.169 1.653 3.275 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 2 49 Ryan Vilade 3 2 CH 85.2 Swinging Strike (Blocked) 1801.0 6.25 -3.7 -17.4 0.122 0.176 1.653 3.275 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 2 50 Junior Caminero 0 0 CH 85.7 Called Strike 2031.0 6.263 -3.2 -14.0 0.703 1.837 1.637 3.244 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 2 51 Junior Caminero 0 1 CH 85.2 Swinging Strike 2034.0 6.238 -2.4 -16.1 1.184 1.508 1.637 3.244 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 2 52 Junior Caminero 0 2 CH 84.1 Ball 2005.0 6.317 0.8 -16.4 1.596 1.524 1.637 3.244 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 2 53 Junior Caminero 1 2 CH 85.2 Ball 2024.0 6.304 -0.7 -17.4 1.927 2.086 1.637 3.244 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 2 54 Junior Caminero 2 2 FF 95.7 Foul 2296.0 6.471 17.5 -6.2 -0.795 3.655 1.637 3.244 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 2 55 Junior Caminero 2 2 CH 85.8 Foul 2048.0 6.293 1.3 -14.6 0.787 2.258 1.637 3.244 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 2 56 Junior Caminero 2 2 SL 84.2 Foul 2520.0 6.474 0.7 4.3 -1.064 2.196 1.637 3.244 Unavailable Unavailable
2026-10-18 2 57 Junior Caminero 2 2 CH 85.8 Swinging Strike 1814.0 6.313 -0.6 -16.9 0.961 1.211 1.637 3.244 Unavailable Unavailable

Reporting notes
  • MLB official final record: statsapi.mlb.com
  • Baseball Savant complete pitch data: baseballsavant.mlb.com
  • The declared regular-season comparison and calculation definitions appear in Sources and method.