MLB

Sonny Gray wanted another batter before Red Sox’s season ended

Boston’s Game 2 pitching change became a focal point after the Yankees completed their Wild Card sweep.

Sonny Gray and the Red Sox during his Game 2 exit at Yankee Stadium
Sonny Gray’s Game 2 exit against the Yankees on September 30, 2026. · Credit: MLB.com

Sonny Gray wanted the opportunity to face Cody Bellinger in the fifth inning Wednesday. Boston instead went to its bullpen, and the Red Sox’s season ended with a 9–2 loss to the Yankees in Game 2 of the American League Wild Card Series.

Gray left after 4⅔ innings and 70 pitches. He was charged with two runs in an outing that ended before Boston’s veteran starter believed his work should be finished.

Bellinger delivered an RBI single against reliever Mason Miller after the change, part of a Yankees offense that eventually pulled away. Gray expressed disappointment afterward, according to The Associated Press’ game report.

The decision makes the exit a distinct part of Boston’s elimination story. A manager can act before a starter reaches a high pitch count because of the next matchup; a starter can still believe he is best equipped to finish that assignment.

Wednesday’s result left Boston with no next game in which to reset. New York completed the two-game sweep, while Gray’s removal became one of the immediate questions surrounding the Red Sox’s finish.

Follow more MLB reporting on The Sporting Page’s MLB desk.

Continue at the source

Read the complete report

This page is an original Sporting Page summary. The reporting remains with Associated Press Game 2 report.

Read at Associated Press Game 2 report

Sources and notes

  1. Associated Press Game 2 report: https://apnews.com/article/e39b4c53a201a1b417d2fecdf9585d86
  2. NBC Sports pitching line, September 30: https://www.nbcsports.com/fantasy/baseball/player-news/2026-09-30/sonny-gray-gives-up-two-runs-in-game-2-defeat
  3. MLB.com postgame reaction: https://www.mlb.com/news/sonny-gray-reacts-to-being-pulled-in-al-wild-card-series-game-2-2026
  4. MLB official Game 2 play-by-play and box score: https://www.mlb.com/gameday/red-sox-vs-yankees/2026/09/30/849848/final/box